Skip to Content
Jack G. Bernstein, Esq., Tampa personal injury lawyer
$500M+
Recovered
Jack G. Bernstein, Esq.
Personal Injury Lawyer

How to Dispute a Car Accident Fault with Other Driver’s Insurance

Blamed for a Crash You Did Not Cause?

Insurers often lean on the officer’s report to decide fault, and a report with errors can shift fault to you. If you disagree, we file your written dispute and appeals with the insurer and can use an accident reconstructionist to show who caused the crash.

$500M+
Recovered
50,000+
Cases Handled
4.9 ★
1,650+ Google Reviews
No fee unless we win
Available 24 hours a day
Free consultation
Injured in an Accident?

Jack’s Got Your Back

Tampa Car Accident Attorney

Navigating the complexities of proving fault for a car accident in Florida can be challenging. So, when you are told you are at fault, it is important to know how to dispute it with help from a Tampa car accident lawyer.

Were you injured in a car accident? Contact Jack Bernstein, Injury Attorneys, now.

The National Trial Lawyers Top 100 badge recognizing elite trial attorneys.
Logo of the Cuban American Bar Association (CABA) featuring blue and red text.
Martindale-Hubbell Client Reviewed badge representing positive client feedback for legal professionals.

Find Out What Your Case Is Worth

Free, confidential evaluation in as little as 5 minutes. Contact us today to speak to Jack personally.

  • No fees unless we win
  • Get an immediate call back. 24/7
  • 100% confidential and privileged
Available 24/7. Or call (813) 333-6666

What Are the Steps to Dispute Car Accident Fault in Tampa, FL?

Florida is a no-fault state, meaning you will initially file your injury and damage claim with your own insurance. If your insurance does not cover all of your losses, you may have grounds to sue the at-fault party. While you do not expect your insurance company to say you were at fault, it is not out of the question. Insurance companies are in business to make money, not pay it out in claims.

So, if the insurance company or the other party says you were at fault, there are specific steps you can follow to dispute it, as follows:

Contest the Insurance Company’s Decision

You have the right to dispute the decision of fault made by your insurance company or the other party.

Contest Any Traffic Violations

If you were issued a citation for a traffic violation, it is important to dispute it. Insurance companies may consider traffic violations when they determine fault, although a traffic citation itself generally cannot be used as evidence at trial (§ 316.650(9), Florida Statutes).

Gather Evidence to Support Your Claim

Evidence is key to showing who was at fault, so you will want to ensure you gather as much evidence as possible.

Review the Police Report for Inaccuracies

Insurance companies often rely on police reports to determine fault. Review the police report for your accident and dispute any inaccuracies.

Get Help from an Experienced Tampa Attorney

The last thing you want to deal with when recovering from a car accident is dealing with filing a dispute about fault and getting the settlement you deserve.
The Record

Over $500 Million in Verdicts and Settlements in Jack’s Career

Jack Bernstein prides himself on achieving outstanding results for his clients and is personally involved in every case and fights for the compensation you deserve.

*Jack Bernstein has worked on the above cases during his career at this firm or another firm. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

See Verdicts & Settlements
Protecting Your Rights for Over 40 Years

Jack G. Bernstein, Esq.

For more than 40 years, personal injury lawyer Jack G. Bernstein, a member of the Florida State Bar Association, the Hillsborough Bar Association, and the Clearwater Bar Association, has protected the rights of individuals injured by a negligent party.

Speak to Jack About Your Case
Jack G. Bernstein, Esq. Personal Injury Lawyer since 1983
Our Commitment

Call Jack, He’s Got Your Back. That’s more than a slogan. It’s our commitment to providing personal attention, responsive communication, and experienced legal representation from start to finish.

Jack Bernstein, Injury Attorneys
  • Practicing Since 1983

    Jack Bernstein has been practicing since 1983. He has obtained over $500 million in verdicts and settlements in his career. Past case results do not guarantee future outcomes.

  • Jack Personally Supervises Every Case

    At Jack Bernstein, Injury Attorneys, Jack personally supervises every case and works closely with our team to help clients pursue the compensation they deserve.

  • We Know How Insurance Companies Work

    We know how insurance companies evaluate claims and the tactics they use to reduce payouts.

  • Experts Who Strengthen Your Case

    Our firm builds every case with those challenges in mind, supported by respected medical, financial, and accident-related experts who help strengthen complex claims.

  • Recognized by Peers and Clients

    Mr. Bernstein’s commitment to excellence has earned him prestigious recognition, including the Martindale-Hubbell AV Preeminent Rating, the Martindale-Hubbell Client Champion Platinum award, and a place among the American Trial Lawyers Association Top 100 Trial Lawyers.

  • At a Glance

Determining Fault in a Car Accident Case

Fault determination in a car accident case depends on police reports, witness statements and insurance company investigations. The accident report issued by the police officer often plays a central role but it can contain errors. Insurance companies tend to prioritize profit over fair compensation so disputing fault effectively requires documenting the accident scene, gathering critical evidence, and notifying your insurance company in writing if you disagree with their fault finding.

How Can I Gather Evidence to Dispute Car Accident Fault?

Evidence should be gathered at the time of the car accident if possible. Yet, when you have severe injuries, this is not possible. Essential evidence you should have are pictures and videos of the accident scene, witnesses’ contact details, and the police report. It is also helpful to record your own testimony on your phone at the time of the accident if you can.

How Long Do I Have to Dispute Car Accident Fault in Florida?

The time you have to dispute car accident liability in Florida can vary based on the insurance company. Generally, you should act quickly once you receive notice that your claim was reduced or denied. Before you can sue your own insurer for overdue PIP benefits, Florida law requires a written notice of intent to initiate litigation, sent once the claim is overdue (§ 627.736(10)(a), Florida Statutes).

Has the Insurer Blamed You?

An insurer’s decision on fault is not the last word, but the time to respond can be short.

Free consultation · No fee unless we win · Available 24/7

What Are My Rights When Disputing Car Accident Fault in Tampa, FL?

Florida Statute 624.155(1) allows any person to bring a civil action against an insurer when that person is damaged by the violations and acts the statute lists, such as an insurer “Not attempting in good faith to settle claims” when it could and should have done so. Before suing, written notice of the violation must first be filed with the state on its form, and no action lies if the insurer pays the damages or corrects the violation within the period the statute sets (§ 624.155(3)). This means you may have a claim against an insurance company that handles a claim in bad faith. You also have the right to file a dispute when you disagree with the initial decision. Additionally, you have the right to hire an experienced personal injury attorney to represent you.

How Can I Prove the Other Driver Was at Fault in a Car Accident?

Proving the other driver was at fault involves gathering sufficient physical evidence to support your claim, including:

  • Pictures
  • Videos
  • Witness statements
  • Your statement
  • Police report
  • Traffic camera and business camera video footage

Hiring an experienced car accident lawyer makes gathering the necessary evidence to prove fault much easier.

What Happens If Both Parties Are Found Partially at Fault?

Florida car accident laws require using comparative negligence when both parties are found partially at fault. This means that any award is reduced by your share of the fault, and if you are found greater than 50 percent at fault for your own harm, you cannot recover damages. This bar applies to negligence cases filed after March 24, 2023.

How Can a Car Accident Attorney Help in Disputing Fault?

A car accident attorney in Tampa has extensive knowledge of Florida tort laws, personal injury laws, and traffic laws. They are familiar with insurance companies’ tactics to deny claims and shift fault. Hiring an attorney provides you with several benefits when disputing fault, including:

  • Your lawyer will gather any additional evidence to show you were not at fault
  • Your lawyer will file all paperwork, documentation, and appeals with the insurance company
  • Your lawyer has access to expert witnesses that could be used to prove you weren’t at fault
  • Your lawyer will challenge any further disputes with the insurance company on your behalf to protect your right to full compensation
  • Legal representation alleviates stress and anxiety associated with disputing fault, allowing you to focus on healing and recovery from your injuries

What Is the Role of an Accident Reconstructionist in Disputing Fault?

An accident reconstructionist is an expert witness whose primary role is to take all the data about the accident and determine the fault. They take the weather conditions, time of day, speed of both vehicles, the direction they traveled, and information from the police report. They plug all this into a complex computer simulation to show precisely how the accident occurred and who was at fault.

Are There Any Specific Florida Laws That Affect How Car Accident Fault Is Disputed?

How car accident fault disputes are handled in Florida is usually determined by the underwriting insurance company’s specific guidelines, policies, and procedures. However, there are a few Florida car accident laws relating to mandatory insurance requirements and deadlines for filing injury claims, as follows:

  • Since Florida is a no-fault state, vehicle owners must carry minimum personal injury protection (PIP) and property damage liability (PDL) coverage (§ 627.733 and § 324.022, Florida Statutes)
  • The Statute of Limitations for filing an injury lawsuit over a car accident is generally two years from the date of the accident for a negligence claim accruing after March 24, 2023

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Have Questions About Your Case?

Every car accident case is different. These answers cover the general rules; what applies to you depends on the facts.

Call us any time, 24 hours a day, and we will go through the specifics with you. It is free, and there is no obligation.

(813) 333-6666 Free Consultation · Available 24/7 Or send us the details online
What Kind of Documentation Is Needed to Dispute Car Accident Fault?

Confused how to dispute a car accident fault? You will need written car accident fault documentation stating why you are disputing it. You should include witness statements, the police report, pictures, and any other relevant evidence to show you were not at fault as part of your dispute.

How Can Witness Statements Help in Disputing Car Accident Fault?

Car accident witness statements can help when disputing car accident fault because this testimony can show that the other party was at fault, not you. It could also change the extent to which you are considered at fault.

What Should I Do If the Insurance Company Denies My Dispute?

If the insurance company denies your dispute, and you do not have a Tampa car lawyer, now is the time to hire one. Your attorney can appeal the decision and is better equipped to help you overturn their decision.

Can Video Footage Be Used to Dispute Car Accident Fault?

Video footage from traffic cameras and businesses near the car accident scene can be used to dispute car accident liability and determine fault.

Can I Dispute Car Accident Fault Without a Lawyer?

You can attempt to file a car accident fault dispute without a lawyer. However, the process is rather complex. The thing to remember is insurance companies have their own lawyers. So, if you want to even the playing field and ensure things shift in your favor, you need a lawyer.

What Role Does the Police Report Play in Disputing Car Accident Fault?

The police report is vital evidence in proving and disputing car accident faults. It contains details about driving conditions, the extent of damage, where damage occurred, and other information that could make it easier to prove fault. However, police reports sometimes contain inaccuracies, so you may need to dispute the report and have it amended.

Are There Any Specific Florida Laws That Affect Fault Disputes?

Yes. Florida Statute §624.155(1) allows civil action against insurers for unfair practices. Florida also requires vehicle owners to carry PIP coverage in amounts set by law (§ 627.733, Florida Statutes) and generally allows two years to file a lawsuit for a negligence claim accruing after March 24, 2023 (§ 95.11(5)(a), Florida Statutes).

Testimonials

What Our Clients Say

Read all our reviews on Google

Testimonial 1 of 6

“I was in a car accident back in September 2021 and was referred to Jack Bernstein’s office. I initially dealt with Tim, who is such a kind, caring, and God-fearing man. Tim explained everything to me and his assistant Bobbie was amazing. After trying to negotiate my settlement and being unsuccessful, Tim asked if I wanted to go to trial I said yes, and in comes Brian. Brian is so down-to-earth, funny, and has this calm demeanor about himself that makes you relax if you’re upset. He also explained everything that was going on with my case and made sure I understood before we ended our call. His assistant. Arianna, is sweet, soft spoken, very detailed, and passionate about her job and helping clients. She made sure I understood what was going on and was always available to answer questions. My case was resolved August 2023 and I can say Brian definitely had my back!!! If you want/need and attorney that will have your back from start to finish, call Jack Bernstein’s office.”
Katura Jackson Sep 20, 2023
“I want to start by saying that I am not one that would normally file a lawsuit over a car accident, however last year a lady ran into the back of my car driving about 40-50 miles per hour while I was at a complete stop. Needless to say I was truly hurt. My sister had used Jack Bernstein in the past and had great results. I contacted Jack's office and I was assigned to work with Kelly. Kelly was amazing! She followed up with me often to let me know how my case was moving along. I finally settled my case and I am so happy that I choose Jack Bernstein. All I can say is He's Got Your Back lol!”
Jan Smith Oct 17, 2022
“Jack Bernstein’s team has been such a lifesaver after I had been rear ended. I’ve never been in a car accident before so the whole post-crash process was completely new and stressful to me. What the insurance offered was not nearly enough to cover the medical expenses that were incurred during the recovery process, but Bernstein’s team made it happen and more.

My case manager, Alyssa, explained the process to me each step of the way, and was happy to answer any questions I needed. She kept in contact with every step of the way. She worked with the doctors who I was comfortable with seeing, and she always made it her priority to heed to my concerns and desires. I did not have to worry about anything other than my recovery process.

Every person in the team I spoke to has been nothing but kind. I thank them for all that they have done for me. They are the epitome of professionalism and expertise!”
S C Nov 12, 2020
“I am just a regular everyday person and have never been in an automobile accident until I was rear ended at a signal light approximately one year ago. As a result of this accident, I suffered severe Spinal Chord injuries that required extensive Cervical Spine surgery. In an instant my life had been changed forever. And being relatively new to Florida (originally from NYS) and Florida's motor vehicle laws, I was really overwhelmed. On a recommendation from a friend, I hired Jack Bernstein Injury Law Attorneys. It was the best decision that I could have made.
My concerns about navigating the Legal System for just Compensation to a life altering automobile accident were immediately put to rest. Everyone at Jack Bernstein Injury Law Offices treated me with the upmost respect and dignity. From the beginning Case Manager Alyssa Santana and attorney Tim Shanahan explained very thoroughly about how the process was going to work and kept me informed every step of the way. Their primary concerns were always about my Health and Recovery going forward and fighting voraciously for every penny that I deserved after this horrible life changing event.
Attorney Tim Shanahan explained to me in Layman's Terms not only the entire process but also the rational and strategies that he was diligently and professionally employing. And Tim Shanahan is a man of integrity and humility. Tim proved to be a Master Negotiator and certainly maximized my Settlement. Mr. Bernstein, please give this talented Esquire a raise, and Alyssa too.
I sincerely thank Alyssa and Tim and everyone at Jack Bernstein Injury Law Offices for their personal attention and professionalism as well as their humility in helping me get through a very very difficult time. They have my highest recommendations as well as my respect.
Regards,
Mark P
A Very Satisfied Client”
Mark Pyc May 21, 2020
“I was involved in a car accident last year and reached out to Law Offices of Jack Bernstein after running into issues with the insurance company not wanting to pay for repairs to my vehicle when It wasn't at fault.
From my first call the entire process was much easier than i ever expected. The team was professional, I had Elaine and Blake with me the whole time. Elaine kept me informed every step of the way and always communicated clearly. I never had to wonder what was happening with my case, and they made a stressful situation much more manageable,
If you ever find yourself needing an attorney after an accident, I highly recommend giving the Law Offices of Jack Bernstein a call. They were a pleasure to work with and I'm thankful for everything that Elaine, Blake and Jack did for me”
patrick nielsen Jun 26, 2026
“I was involved in a really bad car accident about a year back and reached out to this law firm. The communication was amazing and informative with Marlene & Elizabeth (Lizzy). Jack & Brian handled my case way beyond my expectations. I would highly recommend this firm to anybody.”
gina muglia Apr 3, 2024
Free Case Evaluation

We Will Contact You Immediately.

The consultation is free, confidential, and available now. Tell us what happened. We will tell you where you stand.

Call Us Anytime(813) 333-6666
  • No Fees Unless We Win
  • Available 24/7. Get help anytime.
  • Over $500 Million in Verdicts & Settlements in Jack’s Career
  • National Top 100 Trial Lawyer

Find Out What Your Case Is Worth

Free, confidential evaluation in as little as 5 minutes. Contact us today to speak to Jack personally.

Available 24/7. Or call (813) 333-6666

Visit Our Office

Our Law Firm Location

Jack Bernstein, Injury Attorneys4350 W Cypress St Suite 725, Tampa, FL 33607
Available 24/7. Get help anytime.

Jack Bernstein, Injury Attorneys is located on West Cypress Street in the Westshore district of Tampa, minutes from Tampa International Airport and just off I-275, making the office easy to reach from across Hillsborough and Pinellas County.