Florida is one of a handful of U.S. States that uses a no-fault system to resolve many vehicle accident claims. The basic concept is that drivers carry personal injury protection (PIP) insurance that pays part of their own medical costs and lost income after an accident, regardless of who is at fault.
However, there are some notable exceptions. If you’ve been in a Florida car accident, you need to know about the serious injury threshold. Although your Tampa car accident attorney can best explain how this applies to your situation, you may want to understand the basics of this Florida law.
What Is the Florida Serious Injury Threshold?
The Florida serious injury threshold is an exception to Florida’s no-fault law. Florida’s serious injury threshold allows victims of car accidents to recover pain and suffering damages when their injuries meet the threshold.
Car accident victims typically look first to their own PIP no-fault insurance for medical costs and lost income. Economic losses beyond the benefits PIP pays or would pay, such as medical bills above your PIP benefits, can be claimed from the at-fault driver without meeting the threshold. When a victim meets the threshold standards, they can also claim damages for pain and suffering from an at-fault driver whose vehicle carries the no-fault security Florida law requires.
What Is the Florida No-Fault Serious Injury Threshold?
Florida law 627.737 is Florida’s no-fault serious injury threshold. You meet the threshold if you have any of the following injuries:
- Significant and permanent loss of an important bodily function
- Permanent injury within a reasonable degree of medical probability, other than scarring or disfigurement
- Significant and permanent scarring or disfigurement
- Death
You need to meet only one of the qualifying standards to bring a claim for non-economic damages. Whether you meet one of the qualifying conditions depends on the evidence in your case, and before trial the defendant can ask the judge to decide whether you will be able to submit some evidence that you do.
How Does Florida’s Serious Injury Threshold Work?
Typically, when you’re in a car accident in Florida, you look first to your own insurance policy to pay for your damages. To have PIP pay your medical expenses, you must receive initial treatment within 14 days after the crash (§ 627.736(1)(a), Florida Statutes). You submit your damages to your own PIP insurance provider. The insurance company pays part of your medical expenses and lost income, and the amount available for medical expenses depends on a medical-condition test (§ 627.736, Florida Statutes). Under Florida law, you must carry the minimum PIP coverage the law sets, but you may buy more substantial amounts to extend your PIP coverage.
If your injuries meet one of the qualifying thresholds in Florida law 627.737, Florida’s no-fault limitations don’t apply. Instead, the rules of negligence and traditional tort laws apply. The victim may bring a lawsuit against the responsible party. If you meet the standards to bring a claim under Florida law 627.737, your claim can include non-economic damages. You aren’t limited to compensation for only economic damages and lost wages. Instead, you can bring a lawsuit to fully compensate you for all of your damages under Florida tort law including pain and suffering.
The Florida Serious Injury Threshold Is Unique to Each Person
There’s not a lot of guidance when it comes to determining whether an injury meets the threshold. The same type of injury may be more and less serious in different cases. Likewise, an injury that significantly impairs a bodily function for one person may not have the same effects for another person. For example, a 25-year-old athlete may have different limitations from a whiplash injury than an elderly person.
How Do You Prove the Serious Injury Threshold Under Florida No-Fault Law?
Proving the serious injury threshold under Florida no-fault law most often requires using an expert medical witness. The witness can explain medical information to the jury. They can show the jury how your injuries meet one of the qualifying legal standards. Your attorney can help you question the witness effectively and gather the medical information that you need to present an effective case.
Florida Court Cases Interpreting Florida No-Fault Laws
Smiley v. Nelson (District Court of Appeal of Florida, Second District 2001): The Florida Supreme Court overturned a verdict for non-economic damages. The appeals court said that the complainant didn’t meet the threshold, so the jury couldn’t award non-economic damages. The lower court allowed the jury to consider and award certain types of non-economic damages that aren’t explicitly listed in Florida law 627.737. The appeals court said that Florida’s no-fault law is meant to be an exhaustive bar of non-economic damages when the victim doesn’t have a qualifying injury.
Meyer v. Hutchinson (District Court of Appeal of the State of Florida, 2003): If a driver has an insurance policy from another state that includes similar no-fault language, their policy is enough to apply. When a driver has a comparable no-fault policy from another state, the threshold standards apply.
Auto-Owners Ins. Co v. Tompkins (1995): An award for economic damages may include future economic losses when the damages are reasonably certain to occur. A permanent injury is not a prerequisite to recovering for both past economic damages and future economic damages.
Florida No-Fault Law and the PIP Limit
Florida’s no-fault laws are complex. Many people misunderstand the requirements and options under Florida law 627.737. It’s important not to make assumptions about how the law applies to your case without speaking to an experienced Florida no-fault attorney. Here are just some of the lesser-known but important facts about Florida no-fault law:
- You may purchase more than the minimum PIP coverage. If you do, you can receive benefits up to your policy limit regardless of fault.
- It’s possible to have economic damages above your PIP benefits even without meeting the threshold for a traditional tort claim. You may be able to bring a claim to recover your economic damages including projected future economic damages. However, unless you meet the threshold, you can’t claim non-economic damages.
- The qualifications for meeting the threshold depend on your individual case. Even if someone else’s situation doesn’t qualify, the jury makes a personal determination for you by applying the law to your case.
- If the defendant doesn’t think you meet the threshold, they can ask the judge to decide, 30 days before the trial or the pretrial hearing, whichever is first, whether you will be able to submit some evidence that you meet it. If the judge finds that you will not, the judge must dismiss that claim without prejudice. You can work with a medical expert to present evidence that you meet the threshold.
- Florida PIP law doesn’t allow you to recover from a negligent driver the damages for which PIP benefits are paid or payable (§ 627.736(3), Florida Statutes).
Related: Recovering Lost Wages in Personal Injury Case
Tampa Injury Attorneys for No-Fault Threshold Cases
Have you been hurt in a car accident? Do you wonder if your case meets the threshold to bring a traditional tort claim? Let our team of skilled personal injury lawyers explain all of your options under Florida law.Our fully equipped car accident law firm can help you pursue all avenues to win you the compensation that you deserve. Your call is confidential. Call us today.